Columbus and the Price of Instrumentalized Faith When religious imposition turned into war, coercion, and the devaluation of human life in the New World
Writer: Evangelos Dim. Kepenes (November 16, 2026, 15:45)
Columbus's Beliefs: The Second Coming and the Earthly Jerusalem
Columbus lived in the 15th century and acted as a zealous Catholic servant of the Spanish Crown. His motives were not merely commercial or exploratory, but deeply religious. Between 1501 and 1502, with the help of the monk Gaspar Gorricio, Columbus compiled the Book of Prophecies (El Libro de las Profecías), consisting of 84 leaves (of which 70 survive) filled with passages from the Bible, the Psalms, and medieval theologians. Relying on the calculations of Saint Augustine and Cardinal Pierre d'Ailly, Columbus believed that the age of the Earth was predetermined at 7,000 years. He calculated that only 150 years remained until the end of the world and the Second Coming.
In his introductory letter to King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella, Columbus explicitly states that he did not discover the New World through mathematics or maps, but because he fulfilled the prophecies of Isaiah. He describes himself as the "messenger of the New Heaven and the New Earth." Influenced by the 12th-century mystic Joachim of Fiore, he believed that a "Messiah-Emperor" from Spain would liberate the Holy Land. The gold of the Indies was intended exclusively to finance this final Crusade, which would pave the way for the return of Christ.
The "Book of Prophecies": Excerpts from a Messianic Mission
In the introductory letter addressed to King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella, Columbus explicitly records his theological conviction regarding his mission.
On the fulfillment of prophecies: "In this voyage to the Indies, our Lord wished to perform a very manifest miracle... I spent seven years at your royal court, discussing this matter with many people of great authority and knowledge in all the arts. In the end, they concluded that it was all in vain... Yet it happened exactly as our Savior Jesus Christ had said, and as He had spoken earlier through the mouth of His holy prophets."
On human reason versus divine inspiration: "For the execution of the enterprise of the Indies, neither reason, nor mathematics, nor world maps were of any use to me. What the prophet Isaiah had said was simply fulfilled."
On the countdown to the end of the world: "Saint Augustine says that the end of this world must take place in the seventh millennium from its creation... According to the calculations of King Alfonso, approximately 6,845 years have already passed. Therefore, only 155 years remain until the completion of the 7,000 years, when, as I have said, the end of the world will come."
On the recapture of Jerusalem: "The Holy Spirit works in Christians, Jews, Moors, and all others... Who will doubt that this light came from the Holy Spirit, which with marvelous rays of clarity comforted me with His holy and sacred Scriptures, urging me to press forward and continually encouraging me with great urgency for the restoration of the Holy House [of Jerusalem] to the Holy Church?"
The Mystery of His Origin: Theories of Jewish Roots
There is a long-standing theory that Columbus was a Sephardic Jew (or a converso, meaning a Jew who forcibly converted to Catholicism). This theory is based on evidence such as his close relationship with Jewish financiers at the Spanish court, his knowledge of Hebrew scriptures, as well as a recent 2024 Spanish genetic study that showed indications of Jewish ancestry in his remains, although many academics remain skeptical. His voyages were funded by prominent Jewish converts (such as Luis de Santángel), and he hired the Jew Luis de Torres as an interpreter. Columbus set sail on his first voyage in August 1492, at the exact time the Alhambra Decree forced all Jews to leave Spain. Some researchers have argued that he was seeking a new homeland for the persecuted Jews, yet his own writings clearly show that his goal was the Christian conquest of Jerusalem.
Spain's Religious Policy (1493–1542): Faith as a Tool of Conquest
Columbus’s religious vision laid the foundations for the strict religious policy implemented by the Spanish Crown in the New World.
The Papal Bulls (Inter caetera, 1493): Immediately following Columbus's first return, Pope Alexander VI granted Spain sovereignty over the newly discovered territories. The explicit condition was the mandatory Christianization of the indigenous populations.
The Requirement (Requerimiento, 1513): The Spanish Crown drafted an official declaration that the conquistadors were required to read aloud to the indigenous peoples prior to any military attack. The text demanded that they accept the authority of the Pope and the Spanish monarchs and allow the preaching of Christianity; otherwise, it justified war and their enslavement.
The Encomienda System: Spanish settlers were granted tracts of land along with a specific number of indigenous laborers. In theory, the Spaniard was obligated to protect them and teach them the Catholic faith, though in practice, the system led to harsh exploitation and a dramatic population decline.
The Ban on Conversos and Moriscos: Fearing that newly converted Jews (conversos) and Muslims (moriscos) would spread "heresies" in the New World, the Crown prohibited them—as well as their descendants—from traveling to or settling in the Americas without special royal permission.
The Valladolid Debate (1550–1551): The abuses of the conquest sparked intense theological debates within Spain itself, spearheaded by the Dominican friar Bartolomé de las Casas (who had edited Columbus's journals). This led to the enactment of the "New Laws" (Leyes Nuevas, 1542), which formally abolished indigenous slavery, although their full enforcement in the colonies proved difficult.
A Voice of Resistance: The Role of Bartolomé de las Casas
Bartolomé de las Casas (1484–1566) was the foremost defender of the human rights of indigenous peoples during the 16th century, despite having begun his life in the Americas as a colonist and landowner.
His Conversion and Activism: In 1514, shocked by the brutality of the Spanish conquistadors against the indigenous population in Cuba, he freed his own slaves. He became a Dominican friar and dedicated his life to the legal and theological defense of the native peoples.
The Short Account of the Destruction of the Indies (1552): In this famous work, he recorded in chilling detail the massacres, torture, and extermination of millions of indigenous people. The book was translated into many European languages and fueled the so-called "Black Legend" (Leyenda Negra) against the Spanish Empire.
The Valladolid Debate (1550–1551): King Charles V convened a theological council to judge the moral legitimacy of the conquest. Las Casas debated the scholar Juan Ginés de Sepúlveda, arguing that the indigenous peoples are free, rational human beings and that Christianization must only be carried out peacefully, without violence or enslavement.
Las Casas knew Columbus's family personally and was the man who preserved and transcribed the logbook of his first voyage of 1492 (the original was lost). Although he admired Columbus as an explorer, he severely criticized him for his treatment of the indigenous people and for initiating the slave trade.
The Shadow of the Inquisition in the New World
The Inquisition was officially established in the colonies in 1569 by King Philip II, with centers in Lima (Peru), Mexico City (New Spain), and later Cartagena (Colombia).
Who Fell Under Its Jurisdiction: Contrary to popular belief, indigenous populations were exempted from the jurisdiction of the Inquisition after 1571. The Church considered the natives to be "neophytes" lacking sufficient catechism, and therefore they could not be accused of heresy (their religious oversight was handled by local bishops).
The Real Targets: The Inquisition in the Americas primarily targeted European settlers, Protestants (often captured English or Dutch sailors), and above all crypto-Jews (conversos or marranos), who had secretly crossed into the colonies to escape persecution in Spain and Portugal.
Control of Ideas and Books: Beyond enforcing religious orthodoxy, the Inquisition functioned as a mechanism of political and intellectual censorship. It strictly inspected ports and ships, confiscating books deemed heretical, magical, or subversive to royal authority.
Punishments and Operations: Sentences ranged from fines, confiscation of property, and public penance (auto-da-fé) to imprisonment or death at the stake. However, executions in the Americas were comparatively fewer than in Spain—it is estimated that approximately 100 people in total were executed over a period of 250 years.
The Fate of Crypto-Jews in the New Colonies
Despite strict royal prohibitions, thousands of Sephardic Jews who had been forcibly baptized as Christians (conversos) managed to cross into the New World, seeking safety and economic opportunities.
Commercial Prosperity (1580–1640): During the period when the crowns of Spain and Portugal were united, many Portuguese crypto-Jews settled in Mexico, Peru, and Colombia. They dominated international trade (silver, textiles, cacao), creating powerful networks that connected the Americas with Europe.
Secret Religious Life: In public, they appeared as devout Catholics, but inside their homes, they secretly observed Jewish customs. They lit candles on the Sabbath inside closets, avoided pork, and buried their dead according to Jewish law.
The "Great Conspiracy" (1635–1649): Their economic success provoked the envy of local authorities, leading to mass arrests by the Inquisition in Lima and Mexico City. Dozens of families were financially ruined and executed, such as the famous Carvajal family in Mexico.
The Outcome and Preservation of Memory: Those who survived either assimilated completely into the Catholic population or fled to Dutch and English colonies (such as Curaçao, Suriname, and New York), where they could practice their religion freely. Today, many residents in Mexico and the southwestern United States (New Mexico) maintain family customs without knowing their crypto-Jewish origins.
The Imprint on Indigenous Cultures: Long-Term Consequences
The arrival of the Spanish triggered one of the greatest demographic and cultural upheavals in human history, known as the Columbian Exchange.
Demographic Collapse: Diseases brought by the Europeans (smallpox, measles, influenza), to which the indigenous peoples had no immunity, proved deadlier than weapons. Within a century, the native population of the Americas declined by approximately 80% to 90%.
Destruction of Empires and Knowledge: The great civilizations of the Aztecs, Maya, and Inca collapsed. Spanish missionaries destroyed temples and burned thousands of sacred codices (books), wiping out invaluable knowledge of astronomy, history, and writing.
Linguistic and Religious Syncretism: Spanish and Catholicism were imposed as official elements, yet the indigenous peoples incorporated their own traditions into the new religion. A characteristic example is Our Lady of Guadalupe in Mexico, who became associated with the pre-Columbian deity Tonantzin.
Social Stratification (Sistema de Castas): A strict racial hierarchy was created, with those born in Spain (Peninsulares) at the top, followed by Spaniards born in the Americas (Criollos), people of mixed ancestry (Mestizos), and indigenous peoples and African slaves at the bottom. This inequality continues to affect Latin America socially and economically to this day.
Global Dietary Revolution: Despite the devastation, this contact spread staple indigenous crops (potatoes, corn, tomatoes, cacao, tobacco) to the rest of the world, while introducing horses, cattle, wheat, and coffee to the Americas, radically transforming the ecosystem and economy of the entire planet.
How the "Columbian Exchange" Changed Europe
The transfer of plants, animals, and precious metals from the Americas to Europe sparked a massive economic and demographic boom in the Old World.
Elimination of Famines and Population Growth: The introduction of the potato and corn revolutionized agriculture. These crops yielded many times more calories per acre compared to wheat and thrived in poor soils, leading to the doubling of the European population between 1700 and 1900.
Transformation of European Cuisine: Foods that are today considered an integral part of European tradition—such as the tomato in Italy, peppers and paprika in the Balkans and Hungary, as well as chocolate (cacao)—were completely unknown prior to 1492.
Silver Inflation (The Price Revolution): The massive influx of silver and gold from the mines of Potosí (Bolivia) and Mexico flooded European markets. This caused unprecedented inflation in Spain and financed Europe's global trade with Asia.
New Commercial Empires: Tobacco, sugar (which was intensively cultivated in the Caribbean), and coffee became the first global consumer commodities. Their demand gave rise to the modern banking system, major trading companies, as well as the triangular slave trade from Africa.
The Birth of a New World: The Shaping of the Mestizo Identity
The term Mestizo refers to the descendants of Europeans (primarily Spaniards) and indigenous peoples of the Americas, who today make up the majority of the population in countries such as Mexico, Colombia, Peru, and Chile.
The Historical Starting Point: Because the early Spanish conquistadors and settlers were overwhelmingly male, intermixing with indigenous women (sometimes through marriage and frequently through violence) was widespread. Within the colonial hierarchy (Sistema de Castas), Mestizos held an intermediate position, possessing fewer rights than whites but more than indigenous peoples.
From Discrimination to National Symbol (Mestizaje): During the Latin American wars of independence in the 19th century, and especially following the Mexican Revolution (1910), the Mestizo identity was elevated. Intellectuals such as José Vasconcelos promoted the idea of the "Cosmic Race" (La Raza Cósmica), presenting cultural mixing as the authentic, unifying national identity of Latin America.
Cultural Imprint Today: Contemporary Latin American culture is a product of this synthesis. It is reflected in the language (Spanish enriched with thousands of words from Nahuatl and Quechua, such as chocolate, tomato, and condor), in music, in gastronomy, and in religious festivals (such as the "Day of the Dead" in Mexico).
Contemporary Social Challenges: Despite the official celebration of cultural mixing, the social inequalities inherited from colonialism persist. In many countries of the region, social and economic advancement continues to be influenced by European or indigenous physical features.
The Day of the Dead
The Day of the Dead (Día de los Muertos) in Mexico is the most characteristic example of cultural and religious syncretism, as it combines pre-Columbian indigenous rituals with the Catholic traditions brought by the Spanish conquistadors. Here is how this unique celebration was created and shaped:
1. Pre-Columbian Roots (Aztecs and Maya) Before the arrival of the Spanish in 1519, the civilizations of Mesoamerica viewed death not as the end, but as a natural continuation of life.
The Deity Mictecacíhuatl: The Aztecs dedicated an entire month (August) to the goddess of the underworld, Mictecacíhuatl (the "Lady of the Dead"), who watched over the bones of the deceased.
The Use of Skulls: In pre-Columbian art, skulls symbolized death and rebirth. The indigenous peoples kept skulls as trophies and displayed them during ceremonies, believing that the souls of the dead returned periodically to visit the living.
2. Spanish Influence and Merging When Spanish missionaries tried to abolish the "pagan" festivals of the indigenous peoples, they realized it was impossible. Thus, they applied a tactic of integration.
The Change of Dates: The Church moved the indigenous ceremonies from August to November 1 and 2, so that they would coincide with the Catholic feasts of All Saints' Day (November 1) and All Souls' Day (November 2).
The Shift in Tone: While European Catholicism approached death with mourning, fear, and gloom, the indigenous peoples maintained the festive, joyful character of their own customs, creating a celebration that honors the memory of the dead with colors, music, and food.
3. Symbols of This Blend Today Every element of the modern celebration bears the marks of both worlds:
Altars (Ofrendas): Set up in homes and cemeteries, they combine Catholic symbols (crosses, images of Mary, the "handmaid of the Lord," candles) with indigenous elements (yellow marigold flowers, cempasúchil, that guide the souls, copal incense, and the favorite foods of the deceased).
Sugar Skulls (Calaveras): These are the evolution of the ancient Aztec skulls, now made of sugar—a confectionery technique introduced by Spanish friars.
"La Catrina": The famous figure of the skeleton wearing an aristocratic hat was created in the early 20th century by Mexican printmaker José Guadalupe Posada. It satirized Mexicans who renounced their indigenous roots to imitate the European aristocracy, serving as a reminder that death equalizes all people.
Conclusion
Instrumentalized faith, through earthly and violent practices, distorted the message of the Gospel. This history proves that true Christian witness does not stem from coercion, but from the love that sacrifices itself for humanity:
“For in this very manner God loved the world, so that He gave His only-begotten Son, in order that everyone who believes in Him should not perish, but have eternal life” (John 3:16 Grk txt).
-------------------------------------------------